
Reviewed By
Type – Silly, Cute, Provocative
If you like – Farce and comedy, Shakespeare
Second Best Bed: A silly, provocative, farcical take on William Shakespeare
We don’t know much, aside from the most superficial details about the man William Shakespeare. We know the date of his baptism, but not of his birth. We assume he went to the grammar school moments away from the house he was supposedly born in. We know he married a woman named Anne or Agnes Hathaway, who was eight years his senior. They had three children together, Susanna, Judith and Hamnet, who would die during the diphtheria epidemic. Shakespeare would die aged 52, his cause of death is completely unknown.
His will is a scruffy old document written as one running sentence, in which he gives his second-best bed to his wife. What we are left with regarding the life of the most influential writer in human history are a skeleton of documents and the greatest life’s work of literature we may ever see. As an academic who dedicated much of my university career to studying Shakespeare, I sat in absolute disbelief.
Second Best Bed is a one-hour comedy play written by Mae McCubbin that seeks to bridge what we don’t know with what we can only speculate. The story rests on Hathaway as the protagonist, with Shakespeare as the secondary and his characters as supporting roles, emphasising her own story and sidelining Shakespeare in contrast to academic circles.
Shakespeare (Jackson Plail) is a caricature of a buffoonish male artist trapped in a carousel of insecure self-obsession. Regardless if Shakespeare devotees enjoy this portrayal, it is well written by McCubbin and well performed by Plail. Being McCubbin’s first musical, it shows strong promise of a writer capable of transforming the medium to convey storytelling through monologues devised as songs.
Ezri Cranston as Anne Hathaway is a strong emotive performer. Every aspect of her physical performance perfectly conveyed the emotional vulnerability of Hathaway. There is no doubt that audience members witness a performer capable of conveying archetypical conventions that represent a strong but ignored woman in a delicate but naturalistic manner. Rarely is one in the presence of an actor who tells the entire story purely in their own performance. One could strip away the words and the songs and lose nothing on Cranston’s performance alone.
Shakespeare wrote about what makes us, us. He wrote about our humanity, our emotional needs and our ambitions. Sometimes he told us bluntly what we are capable of when we let our grasp slip from our soul. It is only human nature therefore to want context. The lack of primary sources about Shakespeare leaves the plays open to much scholarly interpretation. And it is the notion of the unknown where Second Best Bed misses the mark.
Assumption is allowed to act as a replacement for absence of evidence. There is no proof that Anne Hathaway ever left Stratford upon Avon, but there is nothing to say she did not. Second Best Bed portrays Shakespeare as an artist who creates at the detriment of the women who surround him. A chauvinist whose narcissistic insecurities make it impossible for him to express love without a quill.
What this play must have praise placed upon it is the striking moments that once any of the performers bursts into song, each note flows as if it were a creek upon a mountain. Each actor has a unique voice with notes of robust classical training. Each composition is an original in both its melody and lyrics. Care was obviously taken to structure each tune with a wide vocabulary and strong rhythm. The songs themselves worked as upbeat pop numbers outside of their scripted context.
There is an art to absurdist silliness, and it is present throughout Second Best Bed. Farcical performance is present throughout Shakespeare’s work, and at no point is the artistry lost. Character acting that emphasises exaggerated goofy slapstick humour is a difficult performance technique to perfect, but it is used effectively throughout. It is done in a deeply engaging manner that enhances the portrayal of stock characters from Shakespeare. Lachlan Whatman is a master of this silly physical and vocal humour and in conveying characterswho bounce off their surroundings.
Is Second Best Bed worth seeing in Melbourne?
Everyone who has passed through one of his plays has their own Shakespeare that lives in their heart. An early engraving of a monument sitting above his grave has him holding a sack of grain. The Victorians placed their own romanticised prejudices and gave us the image of a man in a ruff writing under a tree. And today, he is portrayed as he is on this stage. With only words to guide us, Shakespeare belongs to his reader.
The second best would be the one that was used by the married couple. And a couple of years ago, a document was found which indicated that Anne Hathaway had travelled to London with Shakespeare. So take what you see on this stage as a joyous play and enjoy some catchy songs with brilliant vocals.

Tickets and Practical Info for Second Best Bed in Melbourne 🎟️
Sat 21 Nov – 6pm
The Motley Bauhaus
Price and bookings
From $25 to $32
Adult / general $32
Student / concession $18
Tickets: https://whatson.melbourne.vic.gov.au/things-to-do/second-best-bed
Written by Mae McCubbin
Performed by Mae McCubbin, Ezri Cranston, Jackson Plail, Tyson Garner and Lachlan Whatman.

